A progression is underway:

V1.0 Drawings in Mental Models

Drawing is a lens for looking. It’s the vehicle for looking with intent — at models mental, physical, and digital — and showing that you did.

From the first time anyone scratched out a drawing on a cave wall, they instantiated the graphic where it is in-situ within the mental model in formation in their mind. An interplay was underway.

V2.0 Drawing-Model Fusion (2012)

I invented the automatic fusion of drawings in digital models in 2012. See the story here: Drawing-Model Fusion 2012

Fusion, …like recorded sound in (formerly) silent film.

With the popularization of digital modeling by the 1990s, technical drawing continued in its usual role while instantiation into the model remained unaltered since the time of cave painting (V1.0), done by mental exercise alone, unassisted by the digital model.

(OPEN VCS) V3.0

Using digital models to evolve the form
 of expression
, of the vehicle for looking with intent — at models mental, physical, and digital — and showing that you did.

Not only a fusion, but an evolution in form that surfaces the best of both media (model and drawing), in a new form of expression greater than the sum of its parts.

To start conversation I highlight a couple of ideas with a lot of overlap that run through this blog, about thought (thinking) and sight (looking):

  • Whatever it is that does, or is going to do AEC thought—people, or some kind of “AI”, or both—maybe we ought to think a little (now seems a good time), about what AEC thought is. What are we thinking about?
    • What is AEC thought?
  • And with regard to sight, drawing is the vehicle for looking with intent—at models mental, physical, and digital—and showing that you did.
    • What are we looking at, and why?

Consider the overlap between looking and thinking.

When looking with intent at a model, what is the intent, specifically? I describe the answer in 2 columns on 1 page of cyan text on black background, below. You might notice when reading it that if you’d draw a Venn diagram, to check for overlap between:

  1. the intent of the engaged eye when looking at AEC models, and
  2. a description of the nature of AEC thought itself—at a productive level of abstraction neither too general to mean anything nor too specific to see the forest for the trees

…the two overlap almost entirely.

We can propose a possible conclusion:

the act of looking at AEC models (see the 1 pager below) is precisely tuned for efficient, productive alignment with the nature and purpose of AEC thought itself.

The same idea extends to the medium of technical drawing. Drawing innately, manifestly, discernibly is the act and expression of the intentful eye engaged with AEC models.

Looking, thinking, drawing, is an arrow struck bullseye on target at the core, non-optional, essential work of AEC.

The core work of AEC is this: developing models and looking at them in ways that facilitate assurance of their fitness and adequacy.

Here’s what that means in practical terms:

  1. We designate locations of close study.
  2. We check against omission and for good fit.
  3. After due care and attention, we affirm these checks.
  4. In an interplay (or loop) between wide and narrow, field and focus, environment and attention, we set the mind in motion. The motion is thought itself. In the back and forth, understanding grows.
  5. We offer the courtesy of drawing attention to what’s not to be missed.

That’s what drawing is. It’s what looking with intent is. And these overlap almost entirely with what thought is.

The intent really is about getting ourselves into this loop.

The set of drawings is the expression of this loop, both the active experience of it, and a tangible record of it.

The idea of dispensing with that is self-defeating and counterproductive. Like abandoning telescopes for the cosmos. It’s also like refusing to believe that recorded sound ought to be infused (synchronized) into silent film. Many did refuse that including Jack Warner himself in 1926 even 28 years after the first machine demonstrating the fusion of sound into film in 1898:

In September 1926, Jack L. Warner, head of Warner Bros., was quoted to the effect that talking pictures would never be viable: “They fail to take into account the international language of the silent pictures, and the unconscious share of each onlooker in creating the play, the action, the plot, and the imagined dialogue for himself.”[146]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_film#Commerce

Inevitably though, AEC has not dispensed with the vehicle for looking with intent at models (drawing).

It’s misfortune though that AEC software keeps [drawing] caged in a form of expression that predates digital computing by centuries, as if software companies are aware neither of the purpose of drawing, nor that the digital model will take its role inevitably in the formation and form of this fundamental activity: looking with intent at models to evaluate their fitness and adequacy.

The vehicle (medium) for looking with intent at digital models (and showing that you did), looks and feels today, exactly as the vehicle for looking with intent at mental models did long ago, still does, and always did.

So?

Because the core work of AEC is developing models and looking at them in ways that facilitate assurance of their fitness and adequacy, and because that core work was the same 500 years ago as it is today, and because no difference in this condition is made regardless of whether models are:

  • mental models only, or
  • mental and physical, or 
  • both mental and physical, and also digital
    • take note—the cat’s out of the bag: no digital model ever meant anything to anyone without an adequate mental model in formation.

Then we can say without interference that the looking matters, that drawing:

  • isn’t to be wished away, and
  • isn’t to be left stuck forever in its ancient form only, unaltered by digital modeling.

We look, for fundamental reasons.

I repeat them again.
We look, with specific intent:

Money

  • That, above, is why AE firms invest the majority of their resources looking, in these ways for these things. The looking is fundamental, intentful, non-optional.
  • Intentional is being aware that we’re making a choice.
  • Intentful is taking a particular choice, from a range of options, with the aim of achieving a specific outcome/state of affairs. I.e., “we are doing [X thing] because of [specific reasons] with the intent of achieving [very specific Y] as a result.”

https://betterbusiness.substack.com/p/intentful-vs-intentional

What is a model?

Recall the mental model.

The digital model must be as the mental model is, the environment within which the act of looking with intent is expressed and realized.

Digital model underutilization can be resolved by software that increases model utility. Greater model utility will come from re-orienting software to support using models for what they’re best suited:

  • as environment within which AEC professions visualize with intent to develop, and vouch for, models thought through all the way through.
  • The form of that visualization, our equipment for looking at models, our lens, the medium of drawing, will evolve: the act of looking will take place within the digitial model, as it does (and always has done) within the mental model.

Drawing is not representational. It’s no stand in. It’s the only thing that does what it does. Call it a vehicle for looking at models in ways that facilitate assurance of model fitness and adequacy.

Our mind is set in motion by this. No substitute, no stand-in is available for it. It’s us in action sharpening otherwise fuzzy models mental, physical, and digital.

Drawing produces:
1. Sharp models
2. Our understanding of, confidence in, and affirmation of models

The description of what we look for and why, is above, in the 1 pager on black background.

The evolution in form of the equipment for looking, of the lens for looking, is specified at length in v2 and v3 here:

V1.0 Drawings in Mental Models

Drawing is a lens for looking. It’s the vehicle for looking with intent — at models mental, physical, and digital — and showing that you did.

From the first time anyone scratched out a drawing on a cave wall, they instantiated the graphic where it is in-situ within the mental model in formation in their mind. An interplay was underway.

V2.0 Drawing-Model Fusion (2012)

I invented the automatic fusion of drawings in digital models in 2012. See the story here: Drawing-Model Fusion 2012

Fusion, …like recorded sound in (formerly) silent film.

With the popularization of digital modeling by the 1990s, technical drawing continued in its usual role while instantiation into the model remained unaltered since the time of cave painting (V1.0), done by mental exercise alone, unassisted by the digital model.

(OPEN VCS) V3.0

Using digital models to evolve the form
 of expression
, of the vehicle for looking with intent — at models mental, physical, and digital — and showing that you did.

Not only a fusion, but an evolution in form that surfaces the best of both media (model and drawing), in a new form of expression greater than the sum of its parts.